This blog post is based on a video that was shot in St Albans, focusing on the history of the hot cross bun. We spoke with both experts and locals to gather information and stories. The text below is a condensed version of what we learned from these interviews and the discussions we had, bringing to light the fascinating journey of the hot cross bun from its origins to today’s variations.
The hot cross bun, a cherished Easter symbol in the UK and worldwide, carries a tale woven through centuries, shrouded in mystique and tradition. While its origins remain clouded in history’s fog, it is said that the journey of the hot cross bun begins in the 14th century at St Albans Abbey. According to legend, Brother Thomas Rocliffe, a 14th-century monk, crafted the first spiced bun adorned with a cross to feed the poor on Good Friday, giving birth to a tradition that would endure for generations.
This early version of the hot cross bun was more than just sustenance; it was imbued with symbolism and exotic flavours. Ingredients such as cinnamon, cardamom, and grains of paradise from Africa were mixed with dried fruit to create a rich, spiced dough, which was then marked with a cross to symbolise the Crucifixion. This act of charity and devotion laid the groundwork for the bun’s association with Easter and Christian rituals. It was said that grains of paradise only grew in the garden of Eden.
As the tradition of the hot cross bun spread, it intertwined with superstition and regulation. In the Elizabethan era, the bun was caught in the crossfire of religious reform and superstition, leading to decrees by Queen Elizabeth I and later, James I, that restricted its sale to specific holy days: Good Friday, Christmas, and at burials. This regulation was ostensibly to curb the spread of superstition, yet it also underscored the bun’s deep-rooted significance in English culture.
Sailors took hot cross buns to sea, believing they offered protection from shipwreck, while families hung them in kitchens to ward off evil spirits. One poignant tale recounts a widow who left a hot cross bun to hang in a London pub, hoping it would ensure her son’s safe return from battle. These customs highlight the bun’s role not just as a food item but as a talisman, imbued with hopes and prayers for safety and protection.
The hot cross bun’s evolution continued through the centuries, with the 18th century witnessing its rise to prominence in London’s food scene. This period saw the bun becoming a fixture of the capital’s culinary landscape, celebrated in nursery rhymes and literature, symbolising the city’s bustling street life and diverse culinary offerings. The hot cross bun’s fame was not confined to the British Isles; it spread across the globe, carried by the winds of colonialism and trade, adapting to new cultures and tastes.
Today, the hot cross bun is a testament to culinary innovation and community identity. Regional variations infuse local flavours into the traditional recipe, reflecting the diverse tapestry of communities that embrace this Easter treat. From the traditional spiced and fruited buns to contemporary versions with chocolate, apple, or salted caramel, the hot cross bun continues to evolve, delighting taste buds and bringing people together in celebration of Easter and springtime renewal.
So, as Easter approaches and hot cross buns make their annual appearance in bakeries and kitchens alike, let’s appreciate not only their taste but also the rich tapestry of history they represent. It’s a journey that spans centuries and continents, a story of faith, superstition, and celebration, all rolled into a delicious bun that continues to captivate and comfort, year after year.
Further Reading:
William Crump, Encyclopedia of Easter Celebrations Worldwide (2021).
Elizabeth David, English Bread and Yeast Cookery (1980).
The Alban Bun, St Albans Cathedral.
Janine Mendes-Franco, ‘Hot Cross Buns, A Caribbean Easter Tradition’, Global Voices, March 2016.
SUPPORT MY WORK:
